Hong Kong leader Carrie Lam apologised to the public on Sunday with “utmost sincerity and humility” after the second massive protest in a week over a proposed extradition bill that would allow people to be sent to mainland China for trial.
Ms. Lam’s statement came after hundreds of thousands of people clogged the streets in central Hong Kong dressed in black to demand that she steps down, a day after she suspended the extradition bill.
‘Sea of black’ protesters
Hundreds of thousands of black-clad protesters demanded on June 16 that the city’s leader step down over her handling of a bill that would have allowed extradition to China and which sparked one of the most violent protests in decades.
Some carried white carnation flowers and others held banners saying, “Do not shoot, we are HongKonger” — an appeal to police who fired rubber bullets and tear gas at protesters on June 12, injuring more than 70 people.
The protesters formed a sea of black along roads, walkways and train stations across Hong Kong’s financial centre to vent their frustration and anger at Hong Kong leader Carrie Lam.
“Its much bigger today. Many more people,” said one protester who gave her name as Ms. Wong. “I came today because of what happened on Wednesday, with the police violence.”
Loud cheers rang out when activists called through loud hailers for Ms. Lam’s resignation and the cry “step down” echoed through the streets. Protesters also chanted “pursue the black police”, angry at what they feel was an overreaction by police.
Beijing-backed Ms. Lam on June 15 indefinitely delayed an extradition bill that would have allowed people to be sent to mainland China for trial, expressing “deep sorrow and regret” although she stopped short of apologising.
It was a dramatic retreat by Ms. Lam, but for many opponents, a suspension of the bill was not enough and Sunday’s marchers called for it to be scrapped and Ms. Lam to go.
“We want to pressure our government because [they] didn’t respond to our first march,” said Icy Tang, newly graduated from university in Hong Kong. “So we are coming for the second time — and hope she will listen.”
The about-face was one of the most significant political turnarounds by the Hong Kong government since Britain returned the territory to China in 1997, and it threw into question Ms. Lam’s ability to continue to lead the city.
“Carrie Lam refused to apologise yesterday. It’s unacceptable,” said 16-year-old Catherine Cheung. “She’s a terrible leader who is full of lies… I think she’s only delaying the bill now to trick us into calming down.”
Her classmate, Cindy Yip, said, “That’s why we’re still demanding the bill be scrapped. We don’t trust her anymore. She has to quit.”
Critics say the planned extradition law could threaten Hong Kong’s rule of law and its international reputation as an Asian financial hub. Some Hong Kong tycoons have already started moving personal wealth offshore.
Activist investor David Webb, in a newsletter on June 16, said if Ms. Lam was a stock he would recommend shorting her with a target price of zero.
“Call it the Carrie trade. She has irrevocably lost the public’s trust,” Mr. Webb said.
“Her minders in Beijing, while expressing public support for now, have clearly lined her up for the chop by distancing themselves from the proposal in recent days.”
China’s Communist Party mouthpiece, the People’s Daily, said in a commentary on June 16 that central authorities expressed “firm support” for Ms. Lam.
The protests have plunged Hong Kong into political crisis, just as months of pro-democracy “Occupy” demonstrations did in 2014, heaping pressure on Ms. Lam’s administration and her official backers in Beijing.
The turmoil comes at a difficult time for Beijing, which is already grappling with an escalating U.S. trade war, a faltering economy and tensions in the South China Sea.
Chinese censors have been working hard to erase or block news of the Hong Kong protests, wary that any large public rallies could inspire protests in the mainland.
The violent clashes near the heart of the financial centre on June 12 grabbed global headlines and forced some shops and banks, including HSBC, to shut branches.
In a weekly blog post published on June 16, Hong Kong Financial Secretary Paul Chan sounded a reassuring note about the city’s financial position.
“Even if the external environment continues to be unclear and the social atmosphere is tense recently, overall Hong Kong’s economic and financial markets are still operating in a stable and orderly manner,” he wrote.
At the start of the march, protesters paused for a minute’s silence to remember an activist who died from a fall on June 15 near the site of the recent demonstrations.
In the self-ruled island of Taiwan, which China claims as its own, about 5,000 people rallied outside the parliament building in Taipei with banners saying, “No China extradition law” and “Taiwan supports Hong Kong.”
Some of the protesters in Hong Kong also waved Taiwan flags.
The city’s independent legal system was guaranteed under laws governing Hong Kong’s return from British to Chinese rule 22 years ago, and is seen by business and diplomatic communities as its strongest asset.
Hong Kong has been governed under a “one country, two systems” formula since its return to Beijing, allowing freedoms not enjoyed in mainland China but not a fully democratic vote.
Many accuse Beijing of extensive meddling since then, including obstruction of democratic reforms, interference with elections and of being behind the disappearance of five Hong Kong-based booksellers, starting in 2015, who specialised in works critical of Chinese leaders.
Pro-democracy lawmaker Claudia Mo said protests would continue if Ms. Lam does not scrap the bill.
“If she refuses to scrap this controversial bill altogether, it would mean we wouldn’t retreat. She stays on, we stay on,” said pro-democracy lawmaker Claudia Mo.
Asked repeatedly on June 15 if she would step down, Ms. Lam avoided answering directly and appealed to the public to “give us another chance”. Ms. Lam said she had been a civil servant for decades and still had work she wanted to do.
Ms. Lam’s reversal was hailed by business groups including the American Chamber of Commerce, which had spoken out strongly against the bill, and overseas governments.
The U.K. Foreign Secretary Jeremy Hunt said on Twitter, “Well done HK Government for heeding concerns of the brave citizens who have stood up for their human rights.”
China’s top newspaper on Sunday condemned “anti-China lackeys” of foreign forces in Hong Kong.
“Certain people in Hong Kong have been relying on foreigners or relying on young people to build themselves up, serving as the pawns and lackeys of foreign anti-China forces,” the ruling People’s Daily said in a commentary.
“This is resolutely opposed by the whole of the Chinese people including the vast majority of Hong Kong compatriots.”
The Hong Kong protests have been the largest in the city since crowds came out against the bloody suppression of pro-democracy demonstrations centred around Beijing’s Tiananmen Square on June 4, 1989.
Ms. Lam had argued that the extradition law was necessary to prevent criminals hiding in Hong Kong and that human rights would be protected by the city’s courts which would decide on any extradition on a case-by-case basis.
Critics, including leading lawyers and rights groups, have noted China’s justice system is controlled by the Communist Party, and say it is marked by torture and forced confessions, arbitrary detention and poor access to lawyers.